It’s no secret that a toilet is one of the places we visit severally in a day. This is a clear indication that investing in the best toilet seat that’s comfortable, secure, and durable enough to provide several years of great sanitary service is essential.

Good toilet seats are designed to be stable enough to avoid wiggling or moving when sat upon. Even so, with a huge number of different shapes, styles and designs of toilet seats available in the market, finding one that would impress you might take a bit of digging.

Having identified the challenges most homeowners face when shopping for a new toilet seat, we crafted our best toilet seat reviews containing a compilation of 8 finest models.

This being a lengthy review, we understand you might not have the time to go through the many models herein covered. Thus, we recommend going with our top choice, which is the American Standard 5325.010.178 Champion 4 Slow Close Toilet Seat.

1.  American Standard Champion Elongated Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

The American Standard is a legendary company known for producing the finest toilet seats with top-of-the-range features. The Champion 4 Slow Close Toilet Seat appears to be leading the pack this year – and for many reasons.

Aside from being our most recommended choice, the 5325.010.178 Toilet model doubles up as the best elongated toilet seat the world over. If you’re looking for the most comfortable toilet seat, then look no further than this model.

The Champion 4 toilet seat is available in a very comfortable elongated design. It’s made from a durable and heavy-duty plastic, which makes the seat and its cover long-lasting and truly comfy.

Actually, this unit is built using a unique material known as duroplast, which is made to resemble chinaware. This special material makes the seat functional and long lasting.

For extra convenience, the seat entails a slow-close feature, which lets it shut gently and gradually after the closing has been initiated, keeping noise at bay. Besides hindering accidental bangs, slams, and unwanted noise, the slow-close hinges play a pivotal role in preventing your fingers from being crushed against the edge of the toilet bowl.

Slow-close toilets such as this one eliminate accidents and are safer in environments comprising largely of children. This model sports lift-off hinges that make it pretty easy to remove the seat and carry out thorough cleaning and maintenance.

It’s also designed for quick attachment after cleaning and maintenance. Worth noting, the Champion 4 Slow Close Toilet Seat is a universal model that can fit into virtually all the conventional elongated toilets without a hitch.

Installation procedure is a piece of cake. It comes with a clear instructions manual so any avid DIYer can install it without aid. The Champion 4 Elongated toilet seat is currently available in a range of colors including white, black, bone, and linen.

Its overall design is attractive and coordinates with most popular bathroom decors. Investing in this high-performance toilet seat is a sure-fire way to refresh the status of your current toilet.

What We Loved

  • Made from long-lasting duroplast material resembling chinaware
  • Convenient slow-close mechanism minimizes sudden bangs or slams
  • Universally fits all standard elongated toilets
  • Easy lift-off feature permits trouble-free removing and attaching without special tools
  • Hinges are robust enough to meet all toilet requirements

What Could Be Better

  • Cam lock hinges can become loose

2.  Mayfair Toilet Seat 848SLOWB 000

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

Mayfair has been a trusted name in the toilet seat industry for countless years, which explains why the Mayfair 848SLOWB Will Slow Close Toilet Seat has earned a spot in our toilet seat reviews.

This innovative, rounded slow-close toilet is made of high quality molded wood which takes comfort and durability to a whole new level. For extra durability, the back of this rounded seat is cushioned with a vinyl top as well as wooden molded core.

Engineered and designed by Bemis, the product uses Whisper Close technology, which enables the seat and lid to close quietly and gently, preventing accidental slamming or pinched fingers.

The seat sports an all-white theme that makes it one of the most attractive rounded seats with a sleek design. Its all-white hue gives your washroom a super-nice style and aesthetic look.

And since it’s made from wood with a glittery finish, it’s sure to add elegance to your bathroom décor. Also, the choice of durable enameled high-gloss wood improves the resistance to chipping, peeling, fading and scratching – unlike plastic that’s prone to scratching.

The Mayfair 848SLOWB is very comfortable for everyone to sit on. Ideal for people with back problems, this best round toilet seat has a soft padded back that makes it luxurious enough to sit on the toilet for longer without worsening back pains.

An innovative STA-TITE Fastening mechanism helps keep the seat tightly secured to prevent wigging when sat upon. Therefore, this seat neither shifts around nor comes loose, but stays firmly attached to the bowl throughout the entire call of nature.

When it comes to installation, this unit installs with a snap. The STA-TITE Seat Fastening System facilitates easier and trouble-free installation using a wrench.

The Mayfair 848SLOWB features twisted type hinges which are quick and simple to unclip and remove for maintenance or replacement purposes. Interestingly, this seat is compatible with all rounded toilets including American Standard, Kohler, TOTO, and more.

What We Loved

  • Seat closes gently and quietly without slamming
  • No wiggling
  • Durable enameled wood resists scratching and chipping
  • High-gloss finish for added elegance
  • Installs with a snap
  • Unclips instantly for cleaning or replacement

What Could Be Better

  • Frequent exposure to water can degrade the seat faster

3.  Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Elongated Biscuit Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

The Kohler K-4636-96 Cachet Toilet Seat is designed for people who hate a seat that jiggles during use. It comes with Grip-Tight bumpers that add stability and prevent any unintentional slips when you sit on it.

Four equally spaced rubber bumpers securely fit to the rim and effectively prevent the seat from wiggling or shifting. This handy feature allows the seat to be used by everyone, including small kids who still struggle to climb onto the toilet. The bumpers hold the seat firmly in place for safety.

The Kohler Cachet Toilet Seat is constructed out of solid polypropylene plastic. This material is not only durable but also resistant to chipping, fading, and staining.

Another useful highlight is the Quiet-Close lid design, which gently and quietly lowers the lid with minimal touch to avoid the loud crash and possible damage to the lid and bowl. The quiet close technology keeps noise to the lowest while preventing slamming.

This toilet seat features Quick-Release hinges which ensure easy detaching of the seat for convenient cleaning and maintenance. The quick-release function enables you to quickly unlatch the seat from the toilet without the need to use any special tools.

As far as comfortability goes, the Kohler Cachet elongated toilet seat measures approximately 17.93 inches long, 13.81 inches wide and 0.875 inches high when assembled.

These dimensions guarantee a comfortable and ergonomic fit on different kinds of posteriors. Additionally, the seat has a smooth surface with ergonomic contours that provide optimized comfort and stability.

The Kohler Cachet entails a Quick-Attach hardware that ensures a speedy and secure installation. The last step of the installation process involves the application of the Grip-Tight bumpers. The overall seat installation is easy through a DIY approach.

What We Loved

  • Unique Grip Tight bumpers prevent shifting
  • Innovative Quiet-Close technology prevents the seat and lid from slamming
  • Engineered to complement a variety of toilet designs
  • Quick-release hinges facilitate convenient removal and cleaning
  • Quick installation using a Quick-Attach hardware

What Could Be Better

  • Inside seat ring might be too narrow for some users

4.  BATH ROYALE BR620-00 Premium Round Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

The Bath Royale BR620-00 is the best round toilet seat available in the market today. In addition to providing the “royal” toilet experience, it is also convenient enough to fit all standard toilet brands.

This round seat can fit most toilets with mounting-hole spacing of 4.5-6.5 inches. So, you can expect it to be compatible with such brands as Universal Rundle, Kohler, Toto, Crane, Delta, Eljer, Caroma, Bemis and Gerber.

The Bath Royale BR620-00 is made from durable and long-lasting polypropylene, which can hold up to 400 pounds without getting cracked. Polypropylene is a relatively soft and light plastic material that’s non-absorbent and resistant to chemicals and stains.

This seat features 100% pure polypropylene, which has a beautiful and high-gloss finish that neither peels nor fades. The seat and cover do flex, but won’t break, crack or permanently deform. Thus, with proper care it’ll be able to last for years.

The unit also boasts a stainless steel mounting hardware for holding the seat firmly in place to avoid wigging. With 4 Sure Foot bumpers, your weight will be evenly distributed during use, adding to comfort and convenience.

The Bath Royale BR620-00 is arguably the best soft close toilet you can find today. It brings the Soft-Close technology on board, thus preventing annoying slams and accidents.

Unlike other brands, this one can be forced closed repeatedly without any problem, making it ideal for the elderly, kids, and the physically challenged persons – such as those with backache problems. You won’t need to stoop or bend to lower the seat.

What We Loved

  • Durable polypropylene acts as an insulator for keeping the seat warm
  • Ability to hold up to 400 lbs without cracking
  • No-slams technology for quiet closing
  • Compatibility with most toilet brands
  • Great for kids, elderly and physically challenged persons

What Could Be Better

  • Not compatible with bidets, risers or grab bars that install between the seat and bowl
  • No color options

5.  BEMIS 1500EC 000 Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

The Bemis 1500EC 000 Elongated Toilet Seat is a functional, no-frills model targeted at budget-conscious buyers in a residential setup. Despite carrying a lower price tag, this seat is extremely long lasting thanks to the durable enameled wood it’s made out of.

The enameled wood seat sports a superior high-gloss finish that’s resistant to scratching and chipping. This strong wood material is equally elegant, and would definitely uplift the mood of every toilet.

The Bemis 1500EC has a non-irritant elongated shape designed to fit any standard elongated toilet bowl. And the unit is available in 10 different hues.

Installing or changing this best soft close toilet seat is a simple cakewalk. The package is accompanied by non-corrosive bolts and wing nuts that fit it snugly, allowing for quick installation.

To remove the seat, you simply need to unlock the hinges and take it off. This facilitates the easiest maintenance possible. To reattach the seat, just fix the bolt heads and snap them shut.

Although it isn’t entirely flawless, the Bemis 1500EC is one of the good toilet seats offering a stylish design and warm feeling. At such a low price tag, this utilitarian model comes with most of the features found on higher-priced options.

If you’re a budget-conscious buyer looking for a basic toilet seat with a classic look, then it’s hard finding a better value toilet seat than this. You won’t go wrong with the Bemis 1500EC – ever!  

What We Loved

  • Made from a durable enameled wood
  • Very affordable price tag
  • Resistant to chipping and scratching
  • Fits all elongated toilets
  • Installation and maintenance is easy

What Could Be Better

  • Lacks clear installation instructions. However, you can find videos online explaining how to intuitively install the unit.
  • Only ideal for elongated toilet design

6.  KOHLER K-4734-0 Rutledge Elongated White Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

For the best in both worlds of simplicity and versatility, KOHLER K-4734-0 Rutledge Toilet Seat would be the best fit. It has a subtle styling and innovative technology, which make it a unit of its kind.

First off, this unit is engineered to complement an array of toilet designs to meet day-to-day needs and conveniences. It’s installed with Grip-Tight bumpers which hold it steadily in place to prevent slipping, making it ideal for both kids and adults.

KOHLER K-4734-0 is made out of a solid polypropylene material which is known to be resistant to staining, scratching and chipping. This means the toilet will serve you for years to come while still looking new.

Worth noting, this elongated toilet seat features the Quiet-Close technology. This tech function prevents the seat and lid from slamming, so it closes slowly and quietly.

The seat itself incorporates Quick-Release hinges that allow for fast and secure installation. And in terms of maintenance, KOHLER K-4734-0’s Quick-Release hinges let you unlatch the seat from the toilet without any special tools.

What We Loved

  • Four bumpers provide stability under use
  • Durable material construction
  • Quiet-close and quick-release functions
  • Seat has comfortable ergonomic contours

What Could Be Better

  • Rubber covers are so tight and could pop off the bumpers

7.  MAYFAIR 9601CP 378 Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

The MAYFAIR 9601CP 378 Round Toilet Seat is an ideal choice for people who hate the standard white surface most toilet seats come in. Being the best designer toilet seat, it gives you unique options for each of choosing what’s befitting for your washroom.

The seat is availed in different colors ranging from pure white and black to neutral hues like silver, bone or grey. You also get these assortments of color options at an extremely reasonable price tag.

This rounded seat is built from wood with a high-gloss finish that adds elegance to your bathroom décor. Its oak veneer wood finish is naturally beautiful and resistant to splitting, cracking, scratching and staining.

Its molded wood lid also sports a glittery finish that’s durable and reflective of modern contemporary styles. It’s designed to complement all round toilet bowls in the US and Canada, including TOTO, American Standard, Kohler, etc.

This item entails the classic non-tarnish chrome metal hinges that are functional, stylish and long-lasting. This hinge system lets you detach the toilet seat easily for cleaning or maintenance purposes.

What We Loved

  • Comes in multiple color options
  • Simple to use, replace or clean
  • Wood finish is elegant and durable
  • Chrome metal hinges are long lasting
  • Reasonable priced

What Could Be Better

  • Not quiet when closing due to lack of soft-close hinges
  • You may find it difficult to install

8.  MAYFAIR 1848SLOWB 000 Toilet Seat

8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide8 Best Toilet Seats of 2020 – Reviews & Buying Guide

Check More Photos on Amazon

The MAYFAIR 184SLOWB 000 Slow Close Elongated Toilet Seat may come last in our toilet seat reviews. But never make a mistake and underrate its performance!

This model takes pride in a mish-mash of cool features that would feel great to buy or at least recommend to a friend. First of all, this elongated toilet seat is built from a durable enameled wood whose superior high-gloss finish resists chipping and scratching.

Also, thanks to the high-gloss finish, cleaning this toilet seat is a breeze. Aside from the elongated design, the seat spots an impressive white theme which blends with almost all bathroom decorations, making it an attractive choice for people who are so concerned about style.

The elongated blueprint is engineered to fit most elongated toilet bowl brands like TOTO, American Standard, and Kohler. In terms of comfort, the MAYFAIR 184SLOWB 000 Toilet Seat never wiggles.

It consists of a simple STA-TITE fastening system which keeps the seat tightly secured in place without coming loose. This integrated seat fastening technology also guarantees the easiest installation using just a wrench.

Installation involves simply screwing nuts and bolts into the designated holes on the toilet bowl and clipping the seat into place. For quick cleaning or replacement, the seat can be unclipped and removed without a hitch.

This hygienic unclipping option makes maintenance less of a hassle and more of fun. What’s more, the MAYFAIR 184SLOWB 000 Toilet Seat has a slow-close feature that eliminates slamming, disgusting noise and pinched fingers.

What We Loved

  • Installs with a snap
  • No slamming or wiggling
  • Enameled wood finish is resistant to scratching and chipping
  • Compatible with most elongated toilet bowls
  • Easy to replace and clean

What Could Be Better

  • Does loosen a bit over time – but it’s better than other models in the same price point
  • The paint gradually starts fading along the edges where the lid meets the bowl

The Ins and Outs for Choosing the Best Toilet Seat

The toilet seat market is marred by substandard seats that can significantly weigh down your comfort. Thus, it’s always essential to take certain factors into consideration before purchasing the best model for your washroom.

Our guide unearths the ins and outs for choosing the best toilet seats.

  • Shape & Size 

Toilet seats can be rounded or elongated, so you need to choose the right shape that matches your toilet bowl. The seat dimension has to complement your current bowl, and the bolts and screws must be fitting to facilitate easier installation.

You can determine the type of bowl shape you have by measuring the bowl from the front to the middle of the mounting holes. A rounded toilet should measure 16.5 inches whilst an elongated one should be 18.5 inches.

By finding out which kind of toilet bowl you have, it’ll become easier to select the right toilet seat. The right option will be able to go well with the particular shape of the toilet.

  • Material 

Of course, the long-time comfort matters when choosing a toilet seat. Toilet seats can be made of different materials, including sturdy and durable plastic, wood, ceramic, synthetic, etc. 

Synthetic ones are extremely affordable and easy to clean and maintain. If the synthetic material is of premium quality, your skin can touch it all day without causing any injuries.

Seats made from strong plastic tend to last longer than wood, because the latter degrades faster when exposed to moisture. However, plastic seats can be cold to the touch even when it’s hot outside, not to mention the fact that they start showing signs of cracking with repeated cleaning.

We generally recommend seats made of high-quality polypropylene as they’re long-lasting and resistant to scratches, cracks, chips and stains. For those who prefer cheaper options, wooden seats coated in plastic are good budget picks.

  • Consider Padding & Build Quality 

The most comfortable toilet seat most likely comes with the appropriate padding. The correct padding adds a softer and warmer feel, and is more than essential for users recovering from an injury.

In the same breath, it’s better off opting for a firm seat if you injury needs steady support. The same case applies to women who’ve just given birth. Note that with padded seats, transfers from shower benches and wheelchairs are a tad challenging.

When it comes to build quality, make sure you choose a seat that’s strong and stable to avoid wiggling. Non-wiggling seats improve utility and comfort. Overall, we recommend picking a model boasting a mish-mash of comfort, rigidity, utility, and durability.

  • Closing System 

The toilet seat’s closing system is worth considering prior to coughing any buck. We recommend picking the best slow close toilet seat, because the slow-close ability makes the seat silent when closing.

Remember, the loud noise of a slamming toilet seat can be irritating not only to you but also people around you. The soft-close mechanism also increases the lifespan of the toilet seat. But how, you ask? 

Well, soft close toilets eliminate accidental slams and bangs since their joints are well-built to minimize sudden impacts. Due to the robust construction, closing will be gradual and gentle such that it won’t break even if you just drop it.

Furthermore, with soft-closing technique, there’s no need to bend over in order to close the toilet. The hinges do this work perfectly, all without trapping your fingers against the edge of the bowl. On the downside, seats with soft-close mechanism are a bit more expensive, but they’re worth the investment in the long run.

  • Ease of Installation 

Most modern toilet seats are easy to install and remove for cleaning purposes. With the most recent models, installation simply involves attaching the nuts and bolts to the toilet bowl and clipping the seat in place.

You’ll then remove the seat by just unclipping again. It’s best to check the ease of installation when purchasing a toilet seat – and verify whether you’ll need any special tools for installation purposes.

Deciding on the mount type also plays a vital role in how you want your toilet seat attached. In terms of mount types, you’ll be choosing between the standard bolt-and-nut mount and the integral bolt and nut.

The standard design is easier to install, remove, and generally holds the toilet seat firmer. On the contrary, the integral design is considered more attractive, but it requires a drill to remove an older toilet seat making it challenging if this tool is out of reach.

  • Quality of the Bumpers

The quality of the bumpers you have on your toilet seat determines whether the seat will be firmly fixed in place or jiggle when you sit on.

A seat whose bumpers are of poor quality tends to slide around and make a bathroom experience unpleasant. As a matter of fact, it can also ruin the fittings and drastically reduce the toilet seat’s lifespan.

Each time you go shopping for a new toilet seat, always remember to gauge the quality of the bumpers and choose the finest of them all. Good quality bumpers effectively prevent wiggling while the seat is in use.

  • Versatility 

Good toilet seats are versatile enough to be used by every member of the family. There’s no need to buy a toilet seat that’s gonna lock out some of your family members from using it.

When you go shopping, choose a seat that accommodates the personal needs of both the kids and adults. Now that’s what versatility is all about. 

  • Finish, Fit & Style

As mentioned earlier, toilet seats come in an assortment of color choices, shapes, styles and designs. Some models incorporate murals like artistry into the seat and lid to accentuate the mood of the toilet.

Generally, the style and quality of the seat are as vital as its performance. A vibrant toilet is not only comfortable but also inviting, allowing you to “poo-poo” for a couple of minutes in the toilet without getting bored.

As a rule of thumb, always opt for a toilet seat with an appealing style, pool design and finish. That way, you’ll be able to dramatically boost the overall appeal of your washroom.

Final Verdict

From our best toilet seat reviews, it’s crystal-clear that there’s the best toilet seats for everyone depending on what you’re looking to achieve. If you wish to enjoy the most comfortable toilet experience, then the American Standard 5325.010.178 Champion 4 Slow Close Toilet Seat would be the most ideal choice for you.

This elongated toilet seat is sure to upgrade your toilet’s comfort, hygiene, safety and decor. It integrates plenty of useful features that’ll up your toilet moment.

On the contrary, if you’re looking for the most budget-friendly toilet seat, then the Bemis 1500EC 000 Elongated Toilet Seat isn’t a bad choice.

This best value model is well equipped to guarantee the utmost comfort and performance while being gentle on your wallet. As a rule of thumb, we recommend assessing your needs prior to choosing a new toilet seat. That way, you’ll be able to pick the best toilet seat that’s properly aligned to your exact prerequisites.